Fortunate is he who gets his affairs in order early. Take Ryder Cup Europe Ltd., for example. Captain Luke Donald now has a full 22-month term to prepare for the away match in the U.S. at the end of September—compared to just 14 months before Rome 2023, due to Henrik Stenson’s LIV Golf exit. That went pretty well nonetheless. Edoardo “The Brain” Molinari is back on board as vice-captain, bringing his statistical expertise to the table. Rory McIlroy, who’s famously on a quest for motivation and his personal Mount Everest, has crossed the career Grand Slam off his list—but winning the Ryder Cup on American soil remains high on his wish list, alongside lifting the Claret Jug at home. So far, so good for Team Europe.
Most consistent American behind Scheffler
Things look far less organized for the hosts. Apart from Scottie Scheffler, the stars and stripes are running a little flat—players like Schauffele and Morikawa have yet to hit full throttle. The most consistent performer behind the world number one? A certain Keegan Bradley: major champion, eight-time PGA Tour winner, a man with experience and plenty of electrifying energy. Based on current form, he’d be a lock for the U.S. team heading into the home match this September at the infamous Black Course in Bethpage State Park.
The only problem? Bradley has been tapped to serve as team captain. But his win at the Travelers Championship last Sunday has opened Pandora’s box. Ever since, a lively debate has erupted in the U.S. golf world: should there be a Ryder Cup comeback for the playing captain? Columns, podcasts, and social media are bursting with hot takes and opinions—a clear sign of the uncertainty facing Team USA. Despite the home advantage and the individual brilliance on paper, there’s growing doubt whether they can truly embrace the role of favorites at Bethpage Black.
Keegan’s Conflict: He Just Wants to Play
The last time a playing captain led Team USA was in 1963, when none other than Arnold “The King” Palmer—aged 34—guided the Stars and Stripes to a dominant 23–9 victory over what was then a purely British side featuring Peter Alliss and Christy O’Connor Sr. That squad was captained by Scotsman John Fallon, and the venue was the Atlanta Athletic Club—known today as East Lake.
Now, over six decades later, the idea of a playing captain has resurfaced—and not without irony.
Keegan Bradley, by his own account, has always just wanted to play. After being snubbed by Zach Johnson for the 2023 Ryder Cup in Rome, the 2011 PGA Champion sat at home in bitter disappointment, his bags packed and hopes dashed. The upside? He avoided a third Ryder Cup defeat, having already lost in 2012 and 2014. But the sting of rejection lingered—until the PGA of America unexpectedly tapped him as captain for the 2025 home match just outside New York. A surprising move, widely seen as a last-minute solution.
“We want you to be the first playing captain since Arnie.”
Originally, Tiger Woods was the frontrunner for the role. The PGA of America even brought in John Wood as team manager to ease the load. But the superstar hesitated—and eventually declined. Bradley wasn’t Plan B; he was a contingency pick. And the powers that be knew exactly how to sweeten the deal. “Keegan, we want you to be the first playing captain since Arnie,” PGA of America CEO Seth Waugh reportedly told him over the phone. Bradley himself shared that anecdote during his Travelers Championship winner’s press conference.
“My whole life every year I was out here I wanted to play on the Ryder Cup team, and then this would be the first year where maybe I didn’t want to. I just wanted to be the captain and, of course, you know, this is what happens. But we’ll see. I’m going to do whatever I think is best for the team. Whether that’s me on the team — this certainly changes a lot of things. I was never going to play on the team unless I had won a tournament and so that’s changed, but we’ll see.” Keegan Bradley
The question of a dual role has been simmering ever since his appointment. After all, at 39, Bradley is the youngest U.S. captain since Palmer’s 1963 appearance. So far, Captain Keegan has consistently played it down, insisting he wouldn’t “waste a captain’s pick” on himself—and would only consider playing if he qualifies automatically.
“Carefully weigh what’s best for the team”
Bradley’s second Travelers win, following his 2023 triumph, has changed the game—and he admits it himself. Now ranked seventh in the world and ninth in the U.S. Ryder Cup standings, he said: “This changes the story a little bit. I never would’ve considered playing if I hadn’t won. Now I have to very carefully weigh what’s best for the team.”
At this point, the decision seems rather straightforward: come the evening of September 25, Bradley should name himself to the Friday morning fourball session—right after delivering his opening speech. Since 2022, he’s racked up four PGA Tour wins, making him America’s number two behind Scottie Scheffler (with 12). None of the other top-12 in the Ryder Cup points standings come close to matching that form.
Scheffler, for all his brilliance, doesn’t carry the vocal, emotional leadership qualities often needed in the team room. That role might better suit someone like Bryson DeChambeau—or, perhaps more fittingly, Bradley himself, whose fire and spirit have long defined him.
At least two rookies, little depth
Then there’s the depth issue. As it stands, U.S. Open champion J.J. Spaun and Russell Henley (ranked third and fourth in Ryder Cup standings) are all but locked in, meaning two likely rookies will tee it up at Bethpage. The second half of the rankings is even more concerning, with names like Ben Griffin, Harris English, or Maverick McNealy currently in qualifying position.
Of course, much can change over the coming weeks. But if Team USA wants to counter Luke Donald’s blue-and-gold squad—led by Rory McIlroy and packed with gritty characters like Tyrrell Hatton, Shane Lowry, and Jon Rahm—then Bradley may need to look beyond the top 13 when it comes to his captain’s picks. Right now, that would mean players like Patrick Cantlay (14), Sam Burns (15), Cameron Young (17), or Tony Finau (19). But let’s be honest: there’s a reason they’re that far down the list.
Unrealistic and Absurd: Woods as a Ceremonial Figurehead
With a bit of humor, the current situation could be labeled “Keegan’s Conflict.” But in reality, it’s a classic dilemma—one that naturally gives rise to a flood of creative solutions. One charming, albeit utterly unrealistic and borderline absurd scenario? That Bradley does all the heavy lifting in the lead-up to Bethpage, only to hand over the reins to Tiger Woods as a sort of chef de mission—someone who would soak up all the media attention while Bradley quietly focuses on pairings and tee times. It would be a slap in the face for Bradley—and let’s be honest, Woods isn’t going to settle for playing the ceremonial mascot.
A far more likely outcome is that the vice captains take on more responsibility. Veterans like Jim Furyk or Brandt Snedeker could handle public-facing duties and media obligations on-site, giving Bradley space to concentrate on strategy and team dynamics. After all, not all vice captain slots have been filled yet—who knows what cards Team USA still has up its sleeve, especially if Bradley does end up playing and needs someone to step in more prominently.
That said, Bradley has firmly ruled out any kind of abdication:
“I’m definitely staying on as captain. I’m not stepping down or anything like that. I’ve already put too much work into this.”
It’s about the 12 best players …
At the end of the day, the Ryder Cup entourage is large enough—and clearly defined. Most of the logistical and strategic groundwork happens long before the first tee shot. The captain’s job is to oversee, coordinate, and ultimately make the right calls. But his most important task by far? Choosing the twelve best players. Seen that way, the Keegan Bradley situation may already be decided.
